Jump to content
catgirl

1L summer job dilemma - help

Recommended Posts

What would be more beneficial taking into account future articling prospects. A summer job doing research with an appeal court (a job for just one summer) or a 1L summer job at a mid-sized firm with opportunity to work at that firm in 2L and articles? I know that I should not be worrying about articling in my first year but I have a hard time not worrying about the future.

Edited by catgirl

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, catgirl said:

What would be more beneficial taking into account future articling prospects. A summer job doing research with an appeal court (a job for just one summer) or a 1L summer job at a mid-sized firm with opportunity to work at that firm in 2L and articles? I know that I should not be worrying about articling in my first year but I have a hard time not worrying about the future.

Only one of those things leads directly to an articling position, no?

Therefore, if you're after job security, you'd pick that one. 

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
16 minutes ago, catgirl said:

What would be more beneficial taking into account future articling prospects. A summer job doing research with an appeal court (a job for just one summer) or a 1L summer job at a mid-sized firm with opportunity to work at that firm in 2L and articles? I know that I should not be worrying about articling in my first year but I have a hard time not worrying about the future.

Depends where you think you want to article and practice. If you want to clerk and are considering academia, or certain government or non-profit or public interest work, then the research job would be better. If you want to work in a law firm, then the firm job would be better. If you want to go into an area of law likely to be self-starting and involving work in a smaller firm or as a sole, such as criminal, family or immigration law, then pick whichever one appeals to you more, or decline both to work in a clinic if you can. 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
11 hours ago, catgirl said:

What would be more beneficial taking into account future articling prospects. A summer job doing research with an appeal court (a job for just one summer) or a 1L summer job at a mid-sized firm with opportunity to work at that firm in 2L and articles? I know that I should not be worrying about articling in my first year but I have a hard time not worrying about the future.

I would do the research position. Research skills are very important no matter what area of law you go into, and many (perhaps most?) 1Ls dont have a summer job working in a law firm so you won't necessarily be at a disadvantage.

Does this firm even do work you like? Do you even know what areas of law you're interested in? Or would you be accepting the firm position just to have a job and articles lined up? I'm not minimizing the importance of having articles locked-up early, but I worry that by taking this job, you're limiting yourself to practices areas that you might not even be interested in - you're then going to summer twice and article in this area. It's going to be harder for you to branch into a different area of law if you hate the areas that this mid-sized firm practices. 

It's early days, allow yourself to explore your interests a little more before essentially signing up for articles in your second semester of law school.  [Caveat: If this is a mid-sized firm that will give you exposure to a bunch of different areas then it might be a good option, but don't limit yourself early]

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
14 hours ago, catgirl said:

What would be more beneficial taking into account future articling prospects. A summer job doing research with an appeal court (a job for just one summer) or a 1L summer job at a mid-sized firm with opportunity to work at that firm in 2L and articles? I know that I should not be worrying about articling in my first year but I have a hard time not worrying about the future.

I'd do the appeal court work. My view is that the experience working for a court (and for judges or crown counsel, I presume?) will lead to more interesting job options. You'll have lots of opportunities to get experience with firms, and if you were in 2L, I might have different advice. But the research job seems like a particularly unique and a rare opportunity for a 1L. 

I never summered or articled at a firm and mostly took on interesting research positions, internships, and clerkships throughout law school and articling. Now I litigate. I didn't find it too hard to sell my unique experience to law firms of varying types. I also haven't closed the door to other interesting roles. Had I instead simply done 1L through articling at the same firm, that probably would have narrowed my options somewhat. If you know exactly what you want to do, however, as @providence advised above, then you should just get on whatever track gets you there more directly.

Edited by FineCanadianFXs
  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 minutes ago, FineCanadianFXs said:

I'd do the appeal court work. My view is that the experience working for a court (and for judges or crown counsel, I presume?) will lead to more interesting job options. You'll have lots of opportunities to get experience with firms, and if you were in 2L, I might have different advice. But the research job seems like a particularly unique and a rare opportunity for a 1L. 

I never summered or articled at a firm and mostly took on interesting research positions, internships, and clerkships throughout law school and articling. Now I litigate. I didn't find it too hard to sell my unique experience to law firms of varying types. I also haven't closed the door to other interesting roles. Had I instead simply done 1L through articling at the same firm, that probably would have narrowed my options somewhat. If you know exactly what you want to do, however, as @providence advised above, then you should just get on whatever track gets you there more directly.

I am probably earlier in my career than FineCanadianFX but I am also in a typical litigation practice after completing several unusual summer positions, and I would agree with what is said above. I would take the unique job that you likely won't have the opportunity to experience again. Maybe it would be a tougher choice if your options were between summering for a firm and going into the bayou to hunt alligators, but nobody is going to be critical of a summer research position for a court.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is a simple choice. Do you want to do litigation or solicitor work? If you want to litigate, take the job at the appeal court. If you want to do solicitor work, take the job at the firm.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Hey,  I'm moving from BC. I found a place through Kijiji. I had just been scanning the ads regularly. I was going to rent an extra month in July just to secure a place but ended up finding one that started mid August. So my suggestion is keep an eye out there. Also avoid Marda. They were awful and rude when I spoke with them.  As for course enrollment I believe we dont have to first year. I'm under the impression we get registered by the school. I could be wrong but when I was reading the handbook for the MSW/JD program that's what I got from it. I know you can check your uwinsite and at the top where it says applicant click it should drop down and there should be a student option if your account is activated. Mine is not yet. Not sure if others are.  We will also be receiving a welcome package in the beginning of August through mail with more info I believe. 
    • Just to dispel this myth, it isn't really true. Certain fields of law and practices, absolutely. But you can definitely work in Montreal being an Anglo with limited French.
    • Depends on the prof and time of year. Some profs are more helpful than others and some times of year they are busier than others. Some of them don't set rigid office hours but are easily available by appointment. During midterms/exams, office hours will invariably be busier than usual, but still easy to get in to. I find that the best way to have a productive conversation during office hours is to ensure I have compiled clear, narrow questions. It facilitates much more directed conversations and professors tend to be happier to help students who appear to be making efforts to learn rather than simply coming to them asking to be taught the entire course material. For example, I would not go to office hours simply asking for them to explain a topic. I would read about the topic, develop questions I had about it and go to them for clarification/discussion on specific issues I had.
    • I'm in the same boat as you with no hire-back from a public sector organization that would have hired me back if it had the budget (and due to recent budget cuts, it does not). I've applied to about 15 organizations for any positions asking between 0-2 to years of experience since mid April, with the most being at the beginning of May. I've heard back from four so far for interviews. The average response time has been about 1 month from the public sector, and about 2-weeks from the private sector.  I'm in the same situation as you, in that my area of law is niche administrative (municipal and planning) and so I have only been applying to public sector organizations and boutiques in that area.  I've actually had the most success applying outside of Ontario in Alberta. Have you considered relocation? I think it might be the most realistic option given the change of government in Ontario, although, its a financial hit. Good luck!
×
×
  • Create New...