Jump to content
Phokis

Ubc vs u of a

Recommended Posts

Hi everyone.

Just got my acceptance to UBC and now I'm kind of torn.

Initially I'd thought that I'd choose u of a regardless but now I'm not so sure.

I've read the reasons to go to schools and what not but here's some background info:

- ideally I want to work in Toronto, Calgary is a second choice. I'm not so interested in working in Vancouver due to the market and cost of living.

- nyc is a pipedream, but I haven't heard of anyone from U of A working in new york

- I'm honestly kind of sick of Vancouver, but I've never lived in Edmonton and moving to a new place may be nice

- cost wise, I could pay the same for rent and live on my own in Edmonton, whereas I'd definitely have to live with at least one roommate in a probably smaller place in Vancouver.

Anyways, I guess to sum it up my primary concern is my employment outcome. Do I have a better chance of working in Toronto if I go to UBC?

My next big concern I guess is quality of life during school. In Edmonton I'd be living around city center, and people seem to say positive things about the lifestyle there, minus the winter. I went to UBC for undergrad and I honestly found myself bored most of the time, but Vancouver has a much better music and food scene.

Advice would be awesome.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I went from Vancouver to U of A and am articling in Edmonton. If food is a big deal to you, I would say stick to UBC and don't come here. Most everything is regular Canadian fare, with some decent upscale restaurants that charge an arm and a leg. Ethnic restaurants are overpriced and significantly worse in quality (especially Chinese/Japanese). Plus, if you're bored in Vancouver, you will be as bored or more bored here. 

Personally, I prefer sunny days with snow and sub-zero temperatures over 200+ days of gloomy rain, but you'd have to decide which you prefer. 

I'll let the other regular posters debate over which school has better job prospects.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the info!

Would you say the population as a whole is friendlier in Edmonton? And during winter, does the city just turn into a deadzone as everyone hibernates?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, Phokis said:

Thanks for the info!

Would you say the population as a whole is friendlier in Edmonton? And during winter, does the city just turn into a deadzone as everyone hibernates?

Generally, yes. Vancouver is known as a cold city for a reason (although like everything else, you get what you put in I guess?). I'm much happier having left Vancouver, especially in its current state, as someone in their 20s looking to establish a comfortable life somewhere. I miss it sometimes and visit regularly, especially for food tours, but I can't see a balanced life there for myself for at least 5 years. 

I wouldn't say Edmonton completely hibernates in the winter,. You'll in all likelihood get sucked into the law school social vortex unless you make an active effort to expand your social circles. The LSA generally makes a good effort to organize social events, although participation varies wildly from year to year (my year love to go out, the year below ours didn't). 

Learning AB law at U of A might be better for you as a lawyer in Calgary. Again, won't get into your chances in Calgary or whatever because it's too hard to predict. 

 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I, personally... would go to UBC. Better weather, cheaper tuition, sounds like you can live at home(?). You can get placed in either Toronto or Calgary from UBC (not sure about NY from either school).

I've visited Edmonton a number of time and wanted to die (no offence). It's very very suburban with not much to do except shop at the West Ed Mall. Everything closed super early, even on the weekends (my partner and I couldnt find a resturant to eat in past 7). And the winters are brutal. I have family there and they have to change their windshields once a year because they crack from the cold. And the day light is weird lol. In the summer the sun sets at like 11 pm and then in the winter there is like 3 hours of sun. I dunno.  It seems like a nice place to "settle down" later in life but it doesnt appeal to me as someone in mid-20s.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, healthlaw said:

I, personally... would go to UBC. Better weather, cheaper tuition, sounds like you can live at home(?). You can get placed in either Toronto or Calgary from UBC (not sure about NY from either school).

I've visited Edmonton a number of time and wanted to die (no offence). It's very very suburban with not much to do except shop at the West Ed Mall. Everything closed super early, even on the weekends (my partner and I couldnt find a resturant to eat in past 7). And the winters are brutal. I have family there and they have to change their windshields once a year because they crack from the cold. And the day light is weird lol. In the summer the sun sets at like 11 pm and then in the winter there is like 3 hours of sun. I dunno.  It seems like a nice place to "settle down" later in life but it doesnt appeal to me as someone in mid-20s.

I can assure you there are many more things to do in Edmonton than to to WEM, and I have no idea where you were trying to eat because I've never heard of a restaurant closing by 7 on a weekend unless you were in an area that primarily caters to a lunch crowd.

But yes, the OP should probably just stick with UBC.  It sounds like the OP's hometown, and there's lots to be said for staying close to your overall support network.  GOing away to school means completely cutting yourself off from friends and family during a fairly stressful time in your life.  If OP's priority was a job in Calgary than U of A would be the obvious choice, but if he or she wants to go to Toronto then UBC is just as good a choice.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 7/10/2018 at 11:45 AM, Phokis said:

ideally I want to work in Toronto, Calgary is a second choice. I'm not so interested in working in Vancouver due to the market and cost of living.

2

UBC places in Toronto and Calgary. What don't you like about Vancouver's market? Toronto is also an expensive place to live.

On 7/10/2018 at 11:45 AM, Phokis said:

nyc is a pipedream, but I haven't heard of anyone from U of A working in new york

1

UBC can and does place in New York.

On 7/10/2018 at 11:45 AM, Phokis said:

I'm honestly kind of sick of Vancouver, but I've never lived in Edmonton and moving to a new place may be nice

 

There's something to be said about the experience of moving but I will take Vancouver over Edmonton without a second thought.

 

On 7/11/2018 at 12:04 AM, Phokis said:

Would you say the population as a whole is friendlier in Edmonton?

 

 

On 7/11/2018 at 9:40 AM, BigRigButters said:

Generally, yes. Vancouver is known as a cold city for a reason (although like everything else, you get what you put in I guess?).

 

This was weird to read. FWIW I am unapologetic about how much I love Vancouver, but I met my lifelong friends in the city and find most everyone to be friendly. I sought out communities and I was rewarded. Not that Edmonton won't give you this, but I don't understand this as a critique of Vancouver. 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
47 minutes ago, Girby said:

This was weird to read. FWIW I am unapologetic about how much I love Vancouver, but I met my lifelong friends in the city and find most everyone to be friendly. I sought out communities and I was rewarded. Not that Edmonton won't give you this, but I don't understand this as a critique of Vancouver. 

Agreed. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
21 minutes ago, Girby said:

This was weird to read. FWIW I am unapologetic about how much I love Vancouver, but I met my lifelong friends in the city and find most everyone to be friendly. I sought out communities and I was rewarded. Not that Edmonton won't give you this, but I don't understand this as a critique of Vancouver. 

How is what I said a critique? I also lived there for years and met lifelong friends, although it wasn't easy as a transplant. Someone asked for a comparison and I gave my opinion. Also, it's even in the quote: "you get what you put in". 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, healthlaw said:

 

I've visited Edmonton a number of time and wanted to die (no offence). It's very very suburban with not much to do except shop at the West Ed Mall. Everything closed super early, even on the weekends (my partner and I couldnt find a resturant to eat in past 7). And the winters are brutal. I have family there and they have to change their windshields once a year because they crack from the cold. And the day light is weird lol. In the summer the sun sets at like 11 pm and then in the winter there is like 3 hours of sun. I dunno.  It seems like a nice place to "settle down" later in life but it doesnt appeal to me as someone in mid-20s.

Lmao. To the OP and others reading this thread disregard everything this guy just said. Clearly someone is salty about edmonton. OP let me clarify some points for you and others who may be turned off about going to edmonton for law school from this posters unsubstantiated remarks. Source: I've lived in edmonton all my life (high school, undergrad, and law school). 

1) nothing closes "super early" unless its a holiday like Christmas - in which every city would suffer the same problem. There is no restaurant in edmonton that closes past 7 - from a business profit making perspective, that doesn't even make any sense. a simple google search of "restaurants to eat for dinner in edmonton" literally gives you hundreds of results, none of which closes at 7pm.

2) ive been enduring the edmonton winters for years, and not once has my windshield cracked from the cold, and neither has any of my friends. exaggeration at its finest

3) 3 hours of sun in the winter? bro this is edmonton...3 hours north of calgary...this isnt Antarctica. The hours of sunlight we get is comparable to any other city in western canada, including vancouver.

4) "not much to do except shop at west ed mall" .....i'm not even going to bother with that one.

In any event, nothing in your post is correct except for the fact that we have brutal winters. next time you try to bash edmonton with your ignorant views, at least say something that is substantiated by common sense and/or experience.

OP just for reference, if your end goal is toronto/nyc go to UBC. no one from my year that i know of ended up in nyc, and i only know 1 person who ended up in toronto. 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 2018-07-11 at 5:00 AM, GoldmanSachs said:

UBC can get you to Toronto and New York. 7-8 students from UBC are working in Toronto this summer. There are also a few u of a students as well.

Hi again Goldman! Hope everything's going well in Toronto. Do you have a sguestimate as to how many from UBC applied?

 

3 hours ago, Malicious Prosecutor said:

But yes, the OP should probably just stick with UBC.  It sounds like the OP's hometown, and there's lots to be said for staying close to your overall support network.  GOing away to school means completely cutting yourself off from friends and family during a fairly stressful time in your life.  If OP's priority was a job in Calgary than U of A would be the obvious choice, but if he or she wants to go to Toronto then UBC is just as good a choice.

Part of my problem was that in the last two years of my undergrad I just felt "trapped" by Vancouver, and that I was really very disconnected from the school community in general. I guess that might not be as big an issue in law school.

1 hour ago, Girby said:

UBC places in Toronto and Calgary. What don't you like about Vancouver's market? Toronto is also an expensive place to live.

I don't like the idea of out competing so many of my peers in UBC and UVic, ending up with a covetted biglaw job along with its hardships, but then not being able to afford a comfortable life/house for the foreseeable short term between work/loan repayment/cost of living. If I come out with 150k in debt I don't know when I'd be able to own a home in this city. The 20-30k salary difference would at least cover rent comparatively, so I could save/pay off my debts faster.

1 hour ago, Girby said:

This was weird to read. FWIW I am unapologetic about how much I love Vancouver, but I met my lifelong friends in the city and find most everyone to be friendly. I sought out communities and I was rewarded. Not that Edmonton won't give you this, but I don't understand this as a critique of Vancouver. 

I grew up in Regina. Even now when I visit it isn't abnormal to walk by a stranger in a park, say hi and have a nice chat. People are also much more open in say a cafe or bar. That said, I too have many lifelong friends in Vancouver, but they are extensions of social circles and work. For example, I only really made 3 or 4 friends I'm still in touch with from UBC, but that's my personal experience. In Regina I still keep in touch with random people I met when I visited.

Anyways. All this input has been extremely helpful, and thanks for the responses. At this point I'm leaning towards UBC. Hopefully I can find a decent place to live.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
20 minutes ago, CGI said:

Lmao. To the OP and others reading this thread disregard everything this guy just said. Clearly someone is salty about edmonton. OP let me clarify some points for you and others who may be turned off about going to edmonton for law school from this posters unsubstantiated remarks. Source: I've lived in edmonton all my life (high school, undergrad, and law school). 

1) nothing closes "super early" unless its a holiday like Christmas - in which every city would suffer the same problem. There is no restaurant in edmonton that closes past 7 - from a business profit making perspective, that doesn't even make any sense. a simple google search of "restaurants to eat for dinner in edmonton" literally gives you hundreds of results, none of which closes at 7pm.

2) ive been enduring the edmonton winters for years, and not once has my windshield cracked from the cold, and neither has any of my friends. exaggeration at its finest

3) 3 hours of sun in the winter? bro this is edmonton...3 hours north of calgary...this isnt Antarctica. The hours of sunlight we get is comparable to any other city in western canada, including vancouver.

4) "not much to do except shop at west ed mall" .....i'm not even going to bother with that one.

In any event, nothing in your post is correct except for the fact that we have brutal winters. next time you try to bash edmonton with your ignorant views, at least say something that is substantiated by common sense and/or experience.

OP just for reference, if your end goal is toronto/nyc go to UBC. no one from my year that i know of ended up in nyc, and i only know 1 person who ended up in toronto. 

 

I don't need to be salty about Edmonton. You seem to have taken my post personally and it has clearly left you feeling salty. I prefaced my post by saying that I visited the city.. meaning I was speaking from my experience. Having lived in Toronto and NY, these were the views from my experience. You can present alternative perspectives without being a child

Edited by healthlaw

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, healthlaw said:

I don't need to be salty about Edmonton. You seem to have taken my post personally and it has clearly left you feeling salty. I prefaced my post by saying that I visited the city.. meaning I was speaking from my experience. Having lived in Toronto and NY, these were the views from my experience. You can present alternative perspectives without being a child

you're getting the wrong impression, its not that im taking it personally, its the simple fact that a person who is genuinely looking for opinions about potentially attending uofa should not be fed nonsensical views where the OP doesnt know any better. and im just calling you out on it. have you read what you wrote? youve "experienced" 3 hours of sunlight in a city located in central alberta? its scientifically impossible for a city like edmonton to receive 3 hours of sunlight during the day, even if its during winter time. restaurants closing at 7pm? as MP pointed out, there's a 0.0001% chance that on a weekend, a restaurant closes at 7pm for dinner, unless you were looking for a lunch place at dinner time...

theres a difference between speaking from experience, and exaggerating your experiences in a city in such a negative light, that it makes no logical sense and claiming it as "alternative perspectives".

OP, if you have any specific questions about edmonton or uofa in general, PM me and id be glad to help.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, Phokis said:

I grew up in Regina. Even now when I visit it isn't abnormal to walk by a stranger in a park, say hi and have a nice chat. People are also much more open in say a cafe or bar. That said, I too have many lifelong friends in Vancouver, but they are extensions of social circles and work. For example, I only really made 3 or 4 friends I'm still in touch with from UBC, but that's my personal experience. In Regina I still keep in touch with random people I met when I visited.

That's Sask for you! Folks there genuinely love to visit. Though I've lived in three provinces other than Sask, I've yet to see another population that generally just loves to have conversations more than Saskies. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh man, this thread was funny to read. I'm from Van, but I lived in Edmonton for a couple of years (non-law related) and I can see why the city didn't leave a good impression on healthlaw. She did exaggerate though. Restaurants don't close after 7, but the city does die down in the evening (minus Whyte Ave which tends to be more lively all the time). Winters are brutal, but you get way more sun in the winters compared to Vancouver. This isn't even a debate. I'm on my phone so I won't bother looking up the stats, but even without checking it's obvious. As far as the attitude of the people are concerned I do think Albertans are generally more friendly. But i attribute it to the rural nature of the province. Vancouver is a discount Toronto with more traffic and higher costs. That means people have that big-city shit attitude that New Yorkers are famous for. There is also more class division and anxiety in Vancouver. Personally I find Edmonton a lot more pleasant to be in because people aren't always stressed about money and cost of living. 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Exactly. I keep having to remind myself that the index score is moderately reliable at best, and highly speculative at worst.  Does u of a wait till they receive fall grades before extending an offer? Because if that’s the case then I don’t think I’ll receive one (if I do) until January at the earliest.  Stqust, As for your GPA, that’s awesome! I think you’ll be alright based on the applicant profile 
    • I sympathize with you, this situation sucks and is becoming increasingly common as we have more graduates from more schools. If I were in your position I would look at the current year as being paid in experience but looking for something else for next year. I mean, you are probably better off than if you had to do the LPP. On the other hand, I wouldn't personally want to stay with a firm that under-paid me during articling just because they could.  It sounds like you really shot yourself in the foot by being over-eager to find any job and they are taking advantage of you a bit. Why didn't you discuss salary before a firm commitment? But I would want to know a lot more before giving any substantial advice, like what were your credentials like? Were you a top student with good extra-curricular's? What are your finances like? 
    • I went to Osgoode and worked in the admissions department, so I'll give you my thoughts. Based on numbers alone, you have no chance. The people who get into Osgoode with numbers in your range are anomalies and should not be taken as examples (probably less than 10 students out of a class of 290, and most of them were mature students with significant work experience). I say throw in an application to Osgoode but do not hedge your bets on it. Invest your time and energy at other schools like Windsor, that do have a truly holistic process and care more about your personal circumstances and extracurriculars. Osgoode receives 2500+ applications for 290 spots, and there will be people applying with better stats than yours who have similar experiences. I scanned your experiences and it's rather common among the Osgoode student body; this is not to take away from it but to say that it may not be as unique as you think. There were students in my class who came from poverty, who are immigrants, who are racialized minorities, who are LGBTQ, who had family and personal tragedies, who can speak multiple languages (very diverse class), who had significant work and volunteer experiences, etc. Osgoode is one of the most diverse law schools in Canada (along with Windsor and Ottawa). I would also be careful about trying to get an acceptance through a "pity parade" of sorts. Ultimately, Osgoode does want to accept a class of very accomplished individuals, who would benefit the legal profession and bring respect and recognition to the school. Don't be misled by students getting in with lower stats - most of them were mature applicants with 5+ years of work experience under their belt. The average cGPA was a 3.67 and average LSAT score a 162 for the last couple of rounds. To put it into perspective, I had a 160+ LSAT score and 3.7+ GPA and fell into at least four of the "categories" you had listed under your experiences. Good luck and I think you have a shot at other law schools, but not really Osgoode unless you get extremely lucky.  Edit: Reference letters don't make or break an application (unless it's extremely negative). Profreader mentioned this in another thread, but you can't know how strong a reference letter is if you have not read them. Now if you have read them, then it's also subjective based on the person reading the letter. Most law school applicants have good/strong letters in general. 
×